
Manchester City wins court case against Premier League in non-Financial Fair Play dispute
English football club Manchester City have won a major court victory against the Premier League, but while many thought it was a case of 130 allegations of breaches of Financial Fair Play, it quickly became clear that this was not the case. This time, sponsorship rules that applied from 2021 to 2024 were declared invalid.
Recommended
It is about related party transactions (APT), a rule that was intended to prevent clubs like City or Newcastle from making financial gains through lucrative sponsorship deals linked to their owners. Large sponsorship deals, far above market value, were used to inject money into the club's finances, explains Spanish newspaper Marca.
🔺 NEW: The Premier League has been dealt a devastating blow in its legal battle with Manchester City after its sponsorship rules enforced between 2021 and 2024 were declared void.
Read more ⬇️
- Times Sport (@TimesSport) February 14, 2025
In early October, the court, acting through an independent panel, ruled that the Premier League had unlawfully blocked two sponsorship deals with Manchester City. However, Premier League chief executive Richard Masters argued at the time that the court had in fact “upheld” the APT rules and had merely found “certain elements that needed to be changed”.
However, the court again ruled in favor of City, who accused the Premier League of "misleading" other clubs: "The APT rules were completely illegal.", writes the Daily Mail.
BREAKING: The Premier League has suffered a significant setback after a tribunal deemed its sponsorship rules null and void.
An independent panel has sided with Man City and deemed that the league's Associated Party Transaction (APT) regulations were unlawful in their entirety. pic.twitter.com/y2WmHIgY54
- Sky Sports News (@SkySportsNews) February 14, 2025
This ruling could have serious consequences for the Premier League's finances - with the expected cost of covering all the costs of the trial estimated at around €24m. In addition, City could also seek huge damages from the Premier League.
– Any contract that was rejected or had its value reduced under the APT system could now be subject to large compensation payments. If a club believes its competitive performance has been compromised by a decision made under the previous APT system, it can also file a lawsuit – writes the British newspaper.